| Year | Beer | Medal | Event |
| 2016 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Gold | NABA |
| 2016 | Jalapeno Double Haul® IPA | Gold | NABA |
| 2016 | Kombrewski | Silver | NABA |
| 2015 | Biere de Garde | Gold | NABA |
| 2015 | KettleHouse Kommon | Silver | NABA |
| 2015 | Fresh Bongwater™ Hemp Ale | Silver | NABA |
| 2015 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Silver | GABF |
| 2014 | Double Haul® IPA | Gold | World Beer Cup |
| 2014 | Double Haul® IPA | Silver | NABA |
| 2014 | Fresh Bongwater™ Hemp Ale | Bronze | NABA |
| 2012 | BA Brick & Mortar™ Porter | Bronze | NABA |
| 2012 | Unfiltered Double Haul® IPA | Silver | NABA |
| 2012 | Double Haul® IPA | Silver | NABA |
| 2012 | Ginseng Ginger Ale N/A | Silver | NABA |
| 2012 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Bronze | World Beer Cup |
| 2011 | BA Sapped Out™ Maple Stout | Silver | NABA |
| 2011 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Gold | NABA |
| 2011 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Bronze | NABA |
| 2011 | Zula™ Stout | Silver | NABA |
| 2011 | Seeley Axe™ Wit | Bronze | GABF |
| 2010 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Silver | NABA |
| 2009 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Bronze | GABF |
| 2009 | Lake Missoula® Amber | Bronze | NABA |
| 2009 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Gold | NABA |
| 2009 | Olde Bongwater™ Hemp Porter | Bronze | NABA |
| 2008 | Olde Bongwater™ Hemp Porter | Gold | NABA |
| 2008 | Double Haul® IPA | Gold | NABA |
| 2007 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Gold | NABA |
| 2002 | Cold Smoke® Scotch Ale | Silver | NABA |
| 2000 | Olde Bongwater™ Hemp Porter | Bronze | NABA |
| 2000 | Lake Missoula® Amber | Bronze | NABA |